TEL AVIV-JAFFA DISTRICT COURT
CA 35524-11-23
Application No. 16
Before: The Honourable Judge Michal Amit-Anisman
Applicant:
Represented by Adv. Yoav Harris
v.
Respondent:
Represented by Advs. Ofer Rahmani, Ehud Yartzon and Ephraim Aligula
DECISION
Before me is the application of the defendant, Mr. (the "Applicant"), for summary dismissal on the ground of limitation of the claim brought against him by the plaintiff, Mr. (the "Respondent"), in respect of an alleged debt of NIS 5,497,767.
Relevant Background
-
The events underlying the action began in 2009, when the Applicant proposed a business venture to the Respondent under which the Respondent would invest EUR 2,600,000 in a company engaged in trading carbon-emission allowances and would be entitled to profits (the "Funds" or the "Investment"). There is no dispute that the Funds were transferred by the Respondent to the Applicant. The parties dispute whether they were transferred in trust or constituted an ordinary investment carrying the attendant prospects and risks. It is also undisputed that part of the Funds was returned. The dispute concerns the balance and whether the Respondent is entitled to recover it. The amount claimed reflects the balance which, according to the Respondent, remained with the Applicant: EUR 1,102,000.
Summary of the Allegations in the Statement of Claim
-
The Respondent states that he is an Israeli resident and citizen who immigrated from France, and that he lived in France during most of the years relevant to the claim. The Applicant, it is alleged, immigrated from France and has lived in Israel since August 2009.
-
The Respondent alleges that in October 2009 the Applicant approached him and proposed that he invest in FINOTEC (the "Company"), which the Applicant allegedly acquired for EUR 20,000,000. Under the proposal, the Respondent would provide EUR 2,600,000 in exchange for 13% of the Company's shares and weekly profits. The Applicant further allegedly undertook that the principal would in all circumstances be secured by funds held in banks, so that the Respondent's money would be safe and protected and could be recovered at any time, without financial risk.
The Respondent claims that he regarded the Applicant as his trustee and, relying on the Applicant's representations, transferred EUR 2,600,000 to him.
-
At the end of February 2010, five months after the Investment, the promised weekly profits had allegedly not been paid. The Respondent demanded the unpaid profits, repayment of the Investment, and various expenses incurred in raising the Funds. Between February and mid-April 2010, the Applicant allegedly made six payments totalling EUR 81,000 on account of the promised profits.
-
At the end of March or the beginning of April 2010 (the exact date is not pleaded), the parties allegedly met in Eilat. The Applicant is said to have undertaken to return, within ten days in Tel Aviv, the entire principal of EUR 2,600,000 transferred by the Respondent and held by him (the "Meeting"). It is further alleged that, even after repayment, the Respondent would remain a shareholder holding 13% of the Company and would continue to earn profits.
-
It is alleged that between April and September 2010 the Applicant returned EUR 1,498,000 in various payments, leaving EUR 1,102,000 in his hands, without taking account of the promised profits.
-
The Respondent further alleges that he later learned that the Applicant had not acquired the Company; that the Applicant had invested only EUR 1,600,000 for a 7% interest; and that the Company's owners later bought out the Applicant's holding for EUR 1,400,000. It is therefore alleged that the Applicant, with whom the Funds had been deposited as trustee, deceived the Respondent, fulfilled none of his promises, and directly appropriated approximately EUR 1,102,000.
-
The matter escalated when the Applicant's brother was kidnapped by the Respondent. Criminal proceedings were conducted against the Respondent in France for that kidnapping. The Respondent pleads that, in those proceedings, he was prohibited from leaving France or contacting the Applicant in any manner until October 2022, and therefore did not commence proceedings until the present action was filed. He asserts that any contact with the Applicant would have breached French criminal law and exposed him to further criminal proceedings.
-
The Respondent alleges that the Funds were delivered to the Applicant in trust, a trust capable of being proved by implication from an oral agreement, the parties' conduct, and their acts, without a written agreement. He further argues that when shares are acquired in trust, they are registered in the trustee's name rather than the beneficiary's. The Respondent also alleges that the Applicant admitted that a balance remained in his hands; that the French investigating judge's file contains numerous oral and written admissions by the Applicant concerning the Funds he had to return; and that these statements constitute admissions by a party. Letters and demands for repayment were allegedly answered by blanket denials without a substantive response, leading to the filing of this action.